"The clear inner lines - beautifully recorded by Andrew Keener - allow the dark complexities of the first movement's development to unravel." (Stephen Pettit, London Evening Standard). "Mark Elder has emerged as an Elgar conductor of the first rank ... the sound is superlative." (Michael Kennedy, Sunday Telegraph)
"A gorgeous disc, beautifully recorded, and a must for all Elgarians." (Hugh Canning, Sunday Times Classical CD of the Week, 26 September 2004)
"If any more evidence were needed that the Hallé Orchestra has attained a level of excellence not heard since the Barbirolli era, this latest of its own-label discs is it." (Matthew Rye, Daily Telegraph Classics CD of the Week, 9 October 2004)